“The Reports of my death have been greatly exaggerated”
One of Mark Twain’s more famous and incorrectly quoted phrases applies pretty well to Jeff Francoeur. If I were to believe everything I’ve seen written about Frenchy I would think he was a stubborn, less than bright, ego maniac with the bat of a 9 year old girl (no offense to 9 year old girls, I’m sure many of you display more gap power than I ever did).
I can’t speak to Jeff’s intelligence, ego, or tenacity. I’m not alone in that arena, though apparently having any knowledge of such things doesn’t stop snarky bloggers from having all sorts of outlandish boring commentary.
Take a deep breath everyone and relax.
I’m going to use a quote from another blogger. He writes for a highly successful baseball blog, and has pieces published for biggies like ESPN, BP, etc. You name it, and he’s probably written or contributed to them. He’s not a scout, but I trust his analysis of players as if he were. He’s not just a stats geek (though he is one of those). He’s probably been to more minor league games and seen more players than any of us could ever hope to. And he’s a good guy. Why won’t I name him? Because the quote came from casual conversation, I haven’t asked his approval, and I don’t want to name drop. You can choose to trust me or not, its up to you.
People way overreact to the most recent season performance. Would the Braves have considered trading Francoeur for Cliff Lee a year ago? Obviously not. The idea that one season’s worth of performance should be enough to completely change our opinion on players (short of a massive injury) is just a fallacy.
I couldn’t agree with him more. If anything, last year showed us a young player, who is maddeningly inconsistent who frustrates even more because of his potential upside. That’s our problem to work through, not his, your vitriol is wasted and you’d probably be better served taking that same energy and going outside, instead of sitting in front of your computer snickering to yourself that you just burned Jeff Francoeur. 1000 positive comments to your post doesn’t make it right, it just means 1001 people are wrong, and really excited about it.
Francoeur was 24 last year and had his worst major league season. He tinkered endlessly with his stance, saw a significant drop in hits, home runs, obp, slugging, just about everything really. He sat out a game for the first time in his career and even spent all of four days playing for double A Mississippi. All of this after his year 23 season in which he made some great strides. EVERYONE had him pegged for a break out year.
You might think I’m crazy, but for me, the most important item in that last paragraph is that Frenchy was only 24, and for that reason alone everyone should chill out. Is last season concerning? Certainly. Is it the end of the world? Not at all. Seriously guys, all of you out there that actually think the Braves would be better off just releasing him, or trading him for fodder need to get another hobby, this one is stressing you out way too much.
Not only is Jeff a mere 25 this year, but the following GOOD things happened last year:
He maintained the increase in his walk rate that he showed between 2006 and 2007.
His line drive pct on balls put in play was 20.7%, his highest yet as a major leaguer. If you are unfamiliar with this stat, click on over to The Hardball Times and read their explanation. Basically it tells you how often they hit the ball with authority. He ranks in the top 20 in LD% in 2008.
His BABIP was 274, absurdly low and more likely than not to increase towards the mean.
His K rate dropped from 18% to 16%. Strikeouts don’t bother me, but at the same time a ridiculous amount of them coupled with a lousy walk rate says a lot about zone control, and while Jeff has a lot of work to do in that arena, he has made incremental improvements.
Francoeur also had a conditioning program last year that added 20 lbs of muscle to his frame. Instead of adding any power, it appeared to decrease his mobility and caused him to lose a step in the field and on the basepaths.
Jeff is coming in lighter this year, and by all accounts in great condition (lost the bulk from the year prior) and focusing on erasing last year. What all the data (and my eyes) show me, is a player with good bat speed and decent power, with a horrible approach at the plate. From what I’ve read, his approach is vague, coming from the ‘See the ball, hit the ball” school of thought. He needs to have a plan and realize that the pitchers have a plan when they are facing him, he should be actively working to counteract that plan. That’s the mental part of the game, and its an adjustment he hasn’t yet proven he can make. This would be a great year to show that he can.
He might be “The Natural”, but he absolutely has the skill set to be an authority in RF and in the line up. Hopefully he learned from last year and can show he is not the albatross my blog brethren would have you believe he is.